Three powerful tactics to discover hidden innovation opportunities

I vividly remember observing a product manager as he presented his team's next big feature. His enthusiasm was evident but as the meeting progressed, I couldn't help noticing the disconnect between what he thought users wanted and what they actually needed. Despite six months of development and thousands spent on market research, they'd missed a fundamental insight their competitors had already discovered.

This scenario plays out in businesses everywhere, from startups to established corporations. Teams spend countless hours developing solutions without truly understanding the problems they're solving, often resulting in products that fail to gain traction or address genuine customer needs.

Yet I've also witnessed the opposite. Consider this illustrative scenario: imagine a small coffee shop chain that transforms its business by implementing a systematic approach to customer discovery. Rather than guessing what their patrons want, they venture out to where their customers naturally gather, listen carefully to their frustrations, and validate potential solutions before investing significant resources. Within six months, they might increase customer retention by 40% and discover several new service offerings their competitors haven't identified.

The difference between these two scenarios wasn't budget or talent—it was methodology. The coffee shop had embraced a key principle: innovation starts with discovery, not creation.

After working with hundreds of businesses on innovation strategies, I've distilled this approach into three powerful tactics from Innovation Tactics by Tom Kerwin that can help any team discover hidden opportunities their competitors miss.

Three Innovation Discovery Tactics That Uncover Hidden Opportunities

These three tactics work together as a powerful discovery system that helps you find genuine innovation opportunities without wasting resources on solutions nobody wants:

1. Watering Holes: Identifying where your potential customers naturally gather and what they talk about
2. Pain X-Ray: Reading between the lines to uncover the hidden struggles your audience doesn't explicitly state
3. Recruitment Probe: Testing interest in problem-solving before investing in solution-building

Let's explore each tactic through the lens of a fictional case study: Pip's Café, an imaginary coffee shop chain we'll use to illustrate how these approaches might work in a real-world setting.

1. Watering Holes: Seek Out Where Your Audience Naturally Gathers

Most market research happens in artificial environments—surveys, focus groups, or formal interviews. While these methods have their place, they often miss the authentic conversations people have when they aren't prompted by your questions.

Why Watering Holes Work

To truly understand a creature's behaviour, zoologists don't observe them in zoos—they go where the animals naturally gather in the wild. The same principle applies to customer research. By finding and observing the places where your potential customers naturally congregate (both online and offline), you gain unfiltered insights into their genuine concerns, language, and priorities.

How to Find Watering Holes

1. List customer-related terminology
   • Generate 10-15 phrases your audience associates with themselves and the topic
   • Include jargon, techniques, tools, software, services, and how they describe themselves
   • For a coffee shop, examples might include: espresso, specialty coffee, pour-over, barista, single-origin, coffee tasting, etc.
2. Search strategically
   • Use these terms with modifiers like "best," "worst," "reviews," "problems," "tutorial," "forum"
   • Look beyond online spaces—consider where your audience meets in person
   • For coffee enthusiasts, this might include specialized cafés, coffee festivals, tasting events, or roaster open houses
3. Evaluate each potential watering hole
   • Assess whether people are actively engaging and discussing relevant topics
   • Follow leads from one watering hole to another
   • Note patterns in the topics and questions that frequently arise

Fictional Example: Pip's Café

In our fictional scenario, imagine Pip's Café management team wants to innovate beyond traditional offerings. Instead of creating another survey, they might:

- Join several specialty coffee Facebook groups and monitor discussions for two weeks

- Visit local farmers' markets where craft coffee vendors set up stalls to observe customer interactions

- Review popular coffee blogs and the comment sections where readers share their experiences

- Attend coffee tasting events as participants, not vendors

This approach could reveal something unexpected: while most of their innovation efforts had focused on introducing new coffee beans and brewing methods, the most passionate discussions in these watering holes might centre around at-home brewing challenges. They might discover that coffee enthusiasts aren't looking for more variety—they're struggling to recreate café-quality experiences at home.

2. Pain X-Ray: Uncover the Hidden Struggles Behind Customer Comments

Once you've found where your audience gathers, the next step is to develop a deeper understanding of their unstated needs. People rarely express their pain points directly—they hint at them through complaints, jokes, recommendations, and questions.

Why Pain X-Ray Works

Most of us try to hide our struggles or aren't fully conscious of them. However, these pain points leak through in our conversations through specific language patterns and emotional cues. By learning to recognize these patterns, you can identify problems your audience may not even realize they have—creating opportunities for innovations that feel almost magical in their relevance.

How to Perform a Pain X-Ray

1. Capture raw material
   • Record questions, complaints, and emotional responses from your watering hole exploration
   • Note exact phrasing, especially recurring words or expressions
   • Document debates, humour, sarcasm, and expressions of frustration
2. Identify underlying stories
   • For each emotional expression, imagine the story behind it
   • Ask yourself: "What might have happened to make them feel this way?"
   • Look for patterns across different comments and questions
3. Extract deeper needs
   • For each story, identify the underlying needs not being met
   • Consider both functional needs (what they're trying to accomplish) and emotional needs (how they want to feel)
   • Group similar needs into themes or clusters

Continuing Our Fictional Example

In our scenario, when reviewing discussions in coffee enthusiast groups, Pip's Café management might notice recurring patterns such as:

- Numerous questions about water temperature and grind size for home brewing

- Jokes about "expensive coffee gear addiction" and "going down the rabbit hole"

- Frustration about inconsistent results: "Perfect cup one day, undrinkable the next"

- Questions about which measurements matter most for consistent results

Through a Pain X-Ray analysis, they could identify an underlying story: home brewers are overwhelmed by contradictory advice and complex variables. The deeper need isn't more equipment or exotic beans—it's confidence and consistency.

This insight might lead them to develop streamlined brewing guides and a "Coffee Confidence" workshop that could become their most requested service, with participants potentially willing to pay three times what they'd initially planned to charge.

3. Recruitment Probe: Test Interest Before Building Solutions

With insights from watering holes and pain x-rays, you now have hypotheses about what your potential customers truly need. The Recruitment Probe tactic helps you validate these hypotheses by inviting people to discuss their struggles—before you've built anything.

Why Recruitment Probe Works

If you can't find people willing to talk about a problem, you'll struggle to find people willing to pay for a solution. The response to your invitation becomes an early market signal and the conversations themselves provide invaluable insights for shaping your offering.

Additionally, the people who respond become your first potential customers and advocates—they're invested in the problem-solving process from the beginning.

How to Conduct a Recruitment Probe

1. Craft a compelling invitation
   • Describe the struggle using your audience's own language
   • Clearly state you're not selling anything (yet)
   • Offer to share what you've learned from others with similar challenges
2. Make it easy to accept
   • Use automated booking tools or offer specific time slots
   • Schedule conversations within two weeks (longer delays decrease show-up rates)
   • Minimise friction in the sign-up process
3. Set clear pivot triggers
   • Decide in advance what response rate would indicate insufficient interest
   • Be prepared to adjust your approach or hypothesis if needed
   • Example: "We'll reconsider our approach if fewer than 3 out of 20 people schedule a conversation"
4. Distribute your invitation strategically
   • Share in the watering holes you've already identified
   • Use multiple channels appropriate to your audience
   • Start broad and refine your targeting based on responses

Completing Our Fictional Example

To continue our fictional case study, imagine Pip's Café creates a simple invitation for coffee enthusiasts to discuss their home brewing challenges. Here's how their message might read:

"Hello Coffee Lovers! At Pip's Café, we're on a mission to enhance your coffee experience, and we need your input. We understand that brewing café-quality coffee at home comes with unique challenges. We're not here to sell anything; we just want to hear your thoughts and share what we've learned from others like you about getting consistent, delicious results at home."

They might post this invitation in coffee Facebook groups, on community noticeboards near their shops, and share it with their email subscribers. Their pivot trigger could be set at 5 responses from 50 invitations.

In this scenario, the response might exceed their expectations, with many people booking conversations within 48 hours. Even more telling, most conversations could include unprompted questions about whether Pip's was planning to offer solutions for the challenges discussed.

These conversations might reveal specific pain points around measuring coffee grounds precisely, maintaining optimal water temperature, and knowing when to adjust variables based on different coffee beans. This could lead to the development of their most successful new offering: calibrated brewing kits with simplified instructions.

From Tactics to Transformation: Creating an Innovation Discovery System

While each tactic is powerful on its own, they create a comprehensive discovery system when used together:

1. Start with Watering Holes to find where your potential customers naturally gather without your influence
2. Apply Pain X-Ray to uncover the hidden struggles that represent genuine innovation opportunities
3. Use Recruitment Probe to validate interest before investing significant resources

This approach transforms innovation from guesswork into a systematic process of discovery, dramatically increasing your odds of creating solutions people actually want.

Addressing Common Objections

"We don't have time for customer research"

Consider the time you're already wasting by building solutions that may not address real customer needs. A team at a major tech company once shared that they'd spent nine months developing a feature that, when launched, had less than 2% adoption. Just two days of watering hole research would have revealed that the problem they were solving wasn't a priority for users.

These tactics don't require months of work—they can be implemented in days or weeks and save months of misdirected development effort.

"Our industry/product is unique"

Every industry has places where customers gather to discuss their challenges. Whether you're selling enterprise software or handcrafted furniture, your potential customers are having conversations somewhere. The specific watering holes may differ, but the principle remains consistent.

One B2B software company I worked with discovered their most valuable insights not in technology forums but in industry-specific LinkedIn groups where operations managers vented about their daily frustrations.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Asking leading questions that bias people toward confirming your existing ideas
2. Looking for validation rather than insight—be open to discovering your assumptions are wrong
3. Moving too quickly to solutions before fully understanding the problem space
4. Dismissing small sample sizes—even five in-depth conversations can reveal patterns you'd miss in hundreds of survey responses
5. Forgetting to capture exact language that you can later use in marketing your solution

The Difference Between Teams That Innovate and Teams That Imitate

Remember the product manager I mentioned at the beginning? Six months after their feature launch fell flat, his team adopted these three discovery tactics. Their next initiative achieved 78% adoption within two weeks of launch and became a key differentiator for their product.

The difference wasn't that they became more creative. It was that they stopped trying to be creative too soon. By first discovering genuine customer needs, they created space for meaningful innovation rather than superficial imitation of competitors.

In today's competitive landscape, the advantage goes not to those who build the most features or follow the latest trends, but to those who develop a deep understanding of their customers' unarticulated needs. These three tactics provide a systematic approach to gaining that understanding—and transforming it into innovations that truly matter.

Take Your Innovation Process to the Next Level

Ready to transform how your team discovers and develops new opportunities? These tactics are just the beginning of a systematic approach to innovation.

For a complete toolkit of validated innovation practices, Innovation Tactics from Pip Decks gives you 54 practical innovation tools in a beautiful card deck, from customer discovery to idea validation. Each card provides clear instructions and examples you can apply immediately.

Developed through work with hundreds of organisations, these tactics have helped teams across industries transform their approach to innovation—focusing their creative energy on solving problems that matter.

Get Innovation Tactics →

Innovation isn't about sudden flashes of genius—it's about systematically discovering opportunities others miss. Start your innovation transformation today.

"Innovation Tactics has completely changed how we approach new product development. Instead of starting with solutions, we now start with discovery, and our hit rate has improved dramatically." - Charles Burdett, Founder of Pip Decks

---

Nearly there...

Check your inbox to confirm your email.

No spam, no email sharing - ever. Privacy Policy

One of the few newsletters I look forward to.
— Dave Cunningham, Head of DesignOps @ NHS