The Strategy Buy-in Secret: How to make your team actually care about your plans

A senior executive presented what she called a "game-changing strategy" to the entire company. She had charts, data, and a polished PowerPoint. Everyone nodded politely. Six months later, nothing had changed. The strategy document sat gathering dust on the shared drive, and people carried on with business as usual.

This experience wasn't unique. Research from Harvard Business School suggests that 95% of employees don't understand their organisation's strategy. In my years consulting with businesses across sectors, I've witnessed this disconnect repeatedly. Leaders craft brilliant strategies in isolation, then wonder why implementation falls flat.

But I've also seen the opposite phenomenon. A small product team at a tech startup I worked with took a radically different approach. Rather than presenting a fully-formed plan, they invited every team member to help shape their product strategy from day one. The result? Their new feature launch exceeded targets by 150%, with the entire team pulling in the same direction with remarkable energy.

What was their secret? They understood that strategy isn't just about making smart decisions. It's about creating emotional ownership across your entire team. When people help build something, they're invested in seeing it succeed.

Ben Mosior and David Holl (authors of Strategy Tactics) discovered and distilled this three-part framework that turns strategy from a top-down directive into a powerful unifying force. Let me show you how to make your team not just understand your strategy, but genuinely care about making it happen.

The Strategy Ownership Formula: Three Tactics That Create True Buy-in

The following three tactics from Strategy Tactics by Pip Decks provide a framework for creating genuine team ownership of your strategic direction:

1. Give Me a Reason: Craft a compelling vision that emotionally connects your team to the strategy
2. Challenge Statement: Create crystal-clear objectives that eliminate confusion and inspire action
3. Backbrief: Use a military technique to ensure alignment before execution begins

We'll explore each tactic with practical examples from a café owner who used these approaches to transform their business strategy. Whether you're leading a small team or an entire organisation, these tactics can help you build strategies that people genuinely want to implement.

1. Give Me a Reason: The Art of Selling Your Vision

Most leaders make a critical mistake when communicating strategy: they focus on what needs to change without addressing why. The Give Me a Reason tactic helps you craft a compelling narrative that connects emotionally with your team, making them care deeply about the strategic direction.

Why it works

Humans are storytelling creatures by nature. We're wired to respond to narratives that create meaning, not just data points or directives. This tactic leverages that natural inclination by framing your strategy within a larger, emotionally compelling story about your team's purpose and potential.

Research from neuroscience shows that when we experience an emotional connection to a message, we're significantly more likely to remember it and act on it. The Give Me a Reason tactic creates that emotional bridge between abstract strategy and personal motivation.

How to use the Give Me a Reason tactic

1. Create a structured narrative
   • Draft a short, compelling speech that covers three key sections
   • Keep it concise enough to deliver in just a few minutes
2. Establish the current situation
   • Summarise where you are now as an organisation
   • Acknowledge both strengths and challenges
   • Briefly explain how you arrived at this point
3. Paint a compelling vision of the future
   • Describe the ideal future you're working toward
   • Explain why this future matters on a deeper level
   • Connect it to meaningful values and purpose
4. Contrast with an undesirable alternative
   • Describe what happens if you don't pursue this strategy
   • Explain why that outcome would be problematic
   • Create emotional urgency around avoiding this path

Practical application

The owner of Pip's Café faced increasing market pressure and needed to adapt their business model. Rather than simply announcing changes, she crafted a narrative that connected with her team:

"We are at a crucial point due to market changes, with Pip's Café's unique coffee and cozy vibe needing a strategic shift to stay competitive and keep customers happy. We have a strong brand and a passionate team, with our unique coffee and atmosphere as foundational strengths. The evolving market threatens to outpace us if we don't swiftly and effectively adapt. Changes in consumer preferences and new market players have challenged our original model, putting us at this crossroads.

We envision Pip's Café as a community hub, transforming every coffee cup into an experience of joy and connection. This future aligns with our values of community, turning every visit into a moment of connection and belonging. It's a moral failing that such inclusive spaces aren't universally available, as they are essential in today's isolating world.

We resist a future where Pip's Café loses its identity, becoming indistinguishable and disconnected from our community. This future is wrong as it represents a loss of connection and identity, undermining our unique value. Allowing this to happen would mean betraying our community, team, and values, choosing complacency over connection."

This narrative didn't just explain what needed to change, but why it mattered on a deeper level. It connected business necessity to meaningful values, creating emotional investment in the strategic direction.

2. Challenge Statement: Creating Clarity That Catalyses Action

Even with emotional buy-in, teams need absolute clarity about what they're working toward. The Challenge Statement tactic helps you craft an objective so clear that there's no room for misinterpretation, while still inspiring creative problem-solving.

Why it works

As General George S. Patton famously said, "Don't tell people how to do things, tell them what to do and let them surprise you with their results." The Challenge Statement tactic embodies this principle by creating crystal clarity about what success looks like, while leaving room for innovation in how to get there.

This approach recognises that people aren't robots who simply follow instructions. They're problem-solvers who make decisions based on their understanding of the goal. By creating absolute clarity about the destination, you enable your team to find the best path forward.

How to use the Challenge Statement tactic

1. Build on your narrative
   • Use the foundation created by your Give Me a Reason statement
   • Add a clear, action-oriented challenge that follows a specific structure
2. Outline potential outcomes
   • Describe what could be achieved if the team embraces the challenge
   • Make these outcomes specific and meaningful
   • What outcome could we achieve if we tried?
3. Connect to deeper meaning
   • Explain why these outcomes matter on a fundamental level
   • Link them to team values and larger purpose
   • Why does it matter, and what does it mean?
4. Define boundaries
   • Clearly state what actions or approaches are off-limits
   • Explain what types of actions are explicitly encouraged
   • Paint a vivid picture of what success will look like
5. Test for clarity
   • After delivering your statement, ask team members to restate it in their own words
   • Listen carefully to what they heard versus what you intended to communicate
   • Revise until the message is crystal clear to everyone

Practical application

The Pip's Café owner added a Challenge Statement to her narrative that created clear direction while still allowing for creativity:

"By exploring new strategies, we could potentially expand our market reach, creating a more diverse customer base and increasing our overall impact in the industry. This matters because staying relevant ensures our survival and growth, meaning we continue to create cherished community spaces and job opportunities.

Compromising our quality or core values for quick profits is off limits; we won't cut corners that could tarnish our brand's integrity. We encourage creative ideas that enhance customer experience and operational efficiency, especially those that align with our mission of community and connection. Success will look like a bustling cafe filled with satisfied customers, a motivated team, and a brand that resonates with our community's spirit."

After delivering this statement, she asked each team member to write down what they heard. Several staff members misunderstood certain elements, focusing too much on expanding physical space rather than market reach. This feedback allowed her to refine the message for perfect clarity before implementation began.

The key insight here wasn't that her initial message was poor—it was actually quite strong—but that perception varies widely. By testing her communication with the team directly rather than assuming understanding, she was able to identify and address misalignments before they affected execution.

The revised combined narrative and Challenge Statement was concise and powerful, creating a rallying cry that every team member could understand and support. It balanced direction with autonomy, giving clear boundaries while encouraging innovation within those parameters.

Here's the final version she presented to the team:

Dear Pip's Family,

Today, we're at a point where the world outside our doors is changing faster than ever. It's a test of our resilience, but also an opportunity to show just how special we are — not just because of our unique coffee but because of each of you, who pour your heart into every cup and every smile.

We've built a haven here, a place that feels like a second home to many. That's something to be proud of. Now, we must hold onto that warmth while stepping boldly into the future.

We envision a place that's more than a cafe — a vibrant hub where every person who walks in feels a sense of belonging. It's hard to believe that such spaces are so rare, but that's why our mission is so important.

We refuse to become another faceless cafe. We owe it to ourselves and to our community to fight for the heart and soul that make Pip's what it is. The prospect of losing that is unthinkable.

Imagine the possibilities if we channel our passion into innovation. It's not just about keeping the doors open; it's about enriching lives, one cup at a time.

Why does this matter? Because what we create here extends beyond these walls. It's about more than coffee; it's about the moments and memories we foster.

We will not cut corners or lose sight of what makes us 'us'. Instead, we'll seek out ways to enhance the magic of Pip's, be it through our service, our menu, or the stories we share.

Our success will look like this: a bustling cafe, where customers leave happier than when they came in, and where you feel proud and excited to be part of this story.

So, what's next? We roll up our sleeves, bring our ideas to the table, and together, craft the next chapter of Pip's. Your voice and your passion are the secret ingredients to our success.

Let's move forward with the courage and commitment that has always defined us. Here's to us, to Pip's, to our future!

Thank you, each and every one of you, for being the heartbeat of this place.

3. Backbrief: The Military Technique That Prevents Strategy Derailment

Even with emotional buy-in and clear objectives, plans can still go awry during implementation. The Backbrief tactic, borrowed from military planning, helps you identify and address potential issues before execution begins.

Why it works

In the military, lives depend on perfect execution of plans. The Backbrief technique was developed to ensure that everyone understands not just what to do, but why they're doing it and how their actions connect to the larger objective.

By having team members rehearse their intended actions before implementation begins, you create an opportunity to spot misalignments, resource gaps, and potential conflicts while the stakes are still low. This prevents costly corrections later and builds confidence across the team.

How to use the Backbrief tactic

1. Allow preparation time
   • After sharing your narrative and Challenge Statement, give team members a few days to process
   • Ask each person to draft a one-page Intent Statement in response
   • Have them address: "First, I intend to...", "Then, I will...", "This will address the Challenge, because...", and "I'm going to need help with..."
2. Structure the Intent Statements
   • Have each statement include intended actions: "First, I intend to... Then, I will..."
   • Include rationale: "This will address the challenge because..."
   • Specify support needs: "I'm going to need help with..."
3. Hold a sharing session
   • Gather the team and have each person read their Intent Statement aloud
   • After each reading, facilitate a group discussion about expectations and surprises
4. Identify adjustments needed
   • Note areas where intentions are misaligned with the strategy
   • Spot resource conflicts or dependencies between team members
   • Identify gaps where important elements aren't being addressed
5. Refine and repeat
   • Use the insights to refine your Challenge Statement if needed
   • Ask team members to revise their Intent Statements
   • Repeat the process until alignment is "good enough" for successful execution

Practical application

At Pip's Café, the manager shared her Intent Statement during the Backbrief session:

"First, I intend to review our current menu and identify items that we can improve or innovate. Then I will engage with customers to gather feedback on what changes they would like to see. This will address the challenge by ensuring our offerings stay relevant and desirable to our customer base, directly influencing customer satisfaction and retention. I'm going to need help with conducting customer surveys and interpreting their feedback. Collaboration with the marketing team will be crucial to communicate our changes effectively."

During the discussion, the team identified that multiple people were planning customer research activities that could be combined for efficiency. They also spotted that no one had addressed updating their online presence to reflect the upcoming changes.

Based on this feedback, the owner revised her Challenge Statement to include more guidance about coordination and digital presence. Team members then updated their Intent Statements to ensure comprehensive coverage of all strategic elements without duplication of effort.

The owner provided a revised statement that clarified boundaries while empowering the team:

Team, we stand at a crossroads, shaped by the ever-changing market that challenges Pip's Cafe's tradition of unique coffee and a cozy vibe. What's good is that we're renowned for what we do; what's concerning is that we must evolve or risk falling behind. We've reached this point through our commitment to quality and the loyalty of our customers, yet the world outside our doors doesn't stand still.

(Boundaries and Context)
As we move forward, it's crucial to remember our roots. Our innovations will stay true to the essence of Pip's — warmth and exceptional coffee. Each step must enhance our brand, not dilute it. While we encourage creativity, we must keep our vision coherent and our standards uncompromising.

(Permissions and Inspiration)
You are the lifeblood of this cafe, and your ideas will fuel our transformation. I give you the freedom to experiment, to engage with customers, and to bring forth ideas that can redefine the cafe experience. Draw inspiration from the very people we serve — their stories, their preferences, their lives.

(Addressing Challenges and Conflicts)
We know the road won't be easy. Customer retention, amidst a plethora of new trends and competitors, is our battleground. Let's anticipate friction in adopting new methods and be prepared to support one another through these changes. Remember, the challenge is not just external; we must also look within to improve every aspect of our service and offering.

(Our Call to Action)
So, what will we do? We will revitalize our menu, reinvigorate our marketing, and recommit to customer engagement. Your contribution starts today by embodying this intent in every action, every coffee poured, and every customer greeted. Let's not just serve coffee; let's serve an experience that's impossible to replicate.

Together, we will not only imagine a better future for Pip's Cafe but actively build it, one cup at a time.

This process transformed what could have been a chaotic implementation into a coordinated effort where everyone understood not just their own role, but how it connected with others to achieve the overall strategy.

Ways to Use This Strategy Framework

There are multiple approaches to implementing these three tactics depending on your team's needs and time constraints:

• The complete loop: Conduct short, separate sessions for each of the three tactics over an extended period of days, or even weeks. This allows for deeper reflection and integration between each stage.
• Full-day experience: Do it all in one go! Spend the day diving deep and use all three tactics, with plenty of breaks in-between to ensure everyone stays engaged and energized.

Additional Tips for Success

• Take small, bold steps every day instead of changing everything all at once. Strategic transformation is more sustainable when it happens incrementally but consistently.
• Embrace mistakes as learning opportunities. They're how you learn! Don't try to be perfect, but do pay careful attention to failure and what it teaches you.
• Think of this framework as a microscope. You can look through it to explore parts of the situation deeply, but you can't look at everything all at once. Before you dig in, briefly consider which parts of your strategy process need the most attention.

From Strategy on Paper to Strategy in Action

When used together, these three tactics create a powerful progression that transforms strategy from a document into a living force within your organisation:

1. Give Me a Reason creates emotional connection and purpose
2. Challenge Statement provides absolute clarity with room for creativity
3. Backbrief ensures alignment before execution begins

This integrated approach addresses the three main reasons strategies fail: lack of emotional buy-in, unclear objectives, and misalignment during implementation. By systematically tackling each of these barriers, you dramatically increase the likelihood of successful execution.

As you work through these tactics, remember that the goal isn't perfect alignment from day one. You're creating a process of progressive refinement, where each step builds on the last to create deeper understanding and stronger commitment. It's about making strategy development a collaborative journey rather than a presentation event.

Addressing Common Objections

"We don't have time for all this communication"

Consider the time and resources wasted when strategies fail because people aren't aligned. McKinsey research estimates that 70% of change initiatives fail, largely due to employee resistance and lack of management support. The time invested upfront in creating genuine understanding and ownership pays massive dividends during implementation.

"Our strategy needs to remain confidential"

While certain elements of strategy may be sensitive, involving your team doesn't mean sharing everything with everyone. You can adapt these tactics to work at different levels of your organisation, ensuring appropriate information sharing while still creating the benefits of collaborative ownership.

"Our leadership already knows best"

Even the most brilliant strategy is worthless if it isn't executed well. These tactics don't diminish leadership authority; they enhance it by creating the conditions for successful implementation. The most effective leaders understand that their job isn't just to make good decisions, but to ensure those decisions translate into action.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Rushing through the process rather than giving each tactic the time it needs
2. Creating a one-way communication instead of genuinely listening to team feedback
3. Overcomplicating your message with jargon or abstract concepts
4. Failing to connect strategy to meaning beyond business metrics
5. Not allowing for adaptation as new insights emerge during the process

Remember that the goal isn't perfect alignment from day one. These tactics create a process of progressive refinement, where each step builds on the last to create deeper understanding and stronger commitment.

From Strategy Resistance to Strategy Champions

What's most remarkable about this process is how it transforms relationships within the organisation. The line between "management" and "staff" blurred as everyone became co-creators of the café's future. Team members started proactively identifying new opportunities and solving problems without being asked.

This is the true power of strategic inclusion: it doesn't just make your current strategy more effective, it builds an organisational capability for ongoing adaptation and innovation from within. By completing this strategic framework, you've created not just a plan, but a foundation for continuous improvement and collaboration.

Remember that this is only the beginning. The true test comes in how you maintain this collaborative energy as you implement your strategy. Continue to revisit these tactics as circumstances evolve, keeping the dialogue open and ensuring everyone remains connected to your shared purpose and direction.

Transform Your Strategic Leadership

Ready to turn your strategy from a paper document into a powerful force for change? These tactics are just the beginning of what's possible when you approach strategy as a collaborative process rather than a top-down directive.

For a complete toolkit of strategic leadership practices, Strategy Tactics by Pip Decks gives you 54 practical strategy tools in a beautiful card deck. From building compelling visions to ensuring flawless execution, each card provides clear instructions and examples you can apply immediately to your next strategic initiative.

Developed through deep research and real world experience with organisations across industries, these tactics have helped thousands of leaders transform their strategic planning from a periodic exercise into an ongoing capability that drives sustainable success.

Get Strategy Tactics →

The difference between strategies that gather dust and strategies that drive transformation isn't about the quality of the thinking. It's about how you bring people along on the journey.

Based on tactics from Strategy Tactics by Pip Decks.

---

Nearly there...

Check your inbox to confirm your email.

No spam, no email sharing - ever. Privacy Policy

One of the few newsletters I look forward to.
— Dave Cunningham, Head of DesignOps @ NHS